Max Noble
The method
On 12 March 2026, Columbus told its shareholders the year would end with a profit margin of 8 to 10%. On 22 October it said about 6. Between those two dates sits everything on this page.
I check promises that listed companies make in public, and I ask one question: did the number come true? This page is how I answer it, so you can check my work. If a rule changes, the change is dated at the bottom.
Found where it was said. Dated the day it was said.
Two ways in: every leader named in the Morning Brief, and the leaders in the week's news, whether they kept their word or not. For each one I go to what the company said in public: the annual report, the quarterly report, the capital markets day, the earnings call, the stock exchange announcement. The card links to the place the promise was first said: the company's own document where one exists, otherwise a named, reputable outlet.
Promised
The day the promise was made in public, linked to the page it was made on.
Delivered
The day the result was reported, linked to that page.
Checked
The day I wrote the card. It sets the order: newest first.
Last checked
The day I last opened every source again and confirmed the verdict.
All four are kept for every card, and its report page prints when it was promised, delivered and last checked. The dates come from the documents, not from memory. When a company cuts a promise before its deadline, the stamp carries the date of the cut and says provisional.
Four tests. All four.
Public
Made in an annual or quarterly report, at a capital markets day, on an earnings call or in a stock exchange announcement.
A number
Growth, margin, savings, capacity, units. Something you can count.
A deadline
A year, a quarter or a date. A promise without one cannot be broken, so it does not count.
A named person
The chief executive, finance chief or chair who gave it, in that role. The promise stays with the person who made it, not the successor who inherits it; the card says so when a successor now answers for it.
I check listed companies on any exchange, not only companies in trouble, and I record a kept promise with the same care as a broken one. Today that means the largest Nordic and American companies, newest checks first. A promise that is only an ambition, with no number or no date, does not get a card, however grand it sounds.
Five stamps.
Kept
The number was met or beaten by the deadline.
Partly kept
Part of the promise came true, part did not.
Late
It came true, after the deadline.
Broken
The deadline passed and the number did not come true, or the company said it will not.
Quietly dropped
The target was withdrawn, or stopped being mentioned, before its deadline.
On track
Shown, not scored, until the deadline passes.
Provisional. When a company cuts its own promise before the year is over, I stamp it the day the cut is announced, marked provisional on the card. The full-year report makes it final. If the year ends better than the cut suggested, the stamp changes and the change goes in the corrections log below.
Against the middle of the promise.
A miss is measured as a share of what was promised. When the promise is a range, I measure from its middle, because that is what the company asked you to expect. A margin promised at 30% that lands at 28% is two points short, which is about 7% off the promise. The result goes into one of three plain words:
Near miss
Less than 10% off the promise.
Clear miss
10 to 30% off.
Big miss
More than 30% off, or the promise was cut more than once.
A promise with two numbers, say growth and margin, is judged on both. If one came true and the other did not, the stamp is Partly kept, and the miss is measured on the number that fell short.
Everyone starts at 0.
The score runs from −100 to +100, with one decimal, because a record is never a round number. Each settled promise adds or takes away points:
Where it landed
Inside the promised range, the bottom earns nothing and the top earns most. Beyond the top earns more, up to a quarter above it. Below the bottom costs points, the full amount at 40% short. A promise withdrawn costs the full amount. With two numbers, both count equally.
How bold
A multi-year promise to the owners counts a quarter more than ordinary yearly guidance.
When
Early counts more. Late makes a miss cost more.
Track record
Every check halves in weight every three years. The latest counts most.
One check can move the score by up to about 43 points. Earlier versions of this page used fixed steps (kept +5, broken −50) from a start of 100; the table below is kept for the record.
| Stamp | Near miss | Clear miss | Big miss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kept | +5 | ||
| Partly kept | −5 | −10 | −15 |
| Late | −10 | −15 | −20 |
| Broken | −15 | −30 | −50 |
| Quietly dropped | −40 | ||
No floor and no ceiling. A kept promise earns less than a broken one costs, on purpose: keeping your word is the job, not a bonus. A leader enters the ranking only after five settled promises; until then they are listed alphabetically, never by score. A hard year still counts, so the company's own reason sits beside every verdict and you can weigh it yourself. The score measures one thing, whether the number came true. It is not a verdict on anyone's character or honesty.
Columbus, 2026.
- The promise
- A profit margin of 8 to 10% in 2026 (EBITDA: profit before interest, tax and depreciation). Annual report, 12 March 2026, repeated in May and August.
- Who gave it
- Søren Krogh Knudsen, CEO and President.
- Four tests
- Public, a number, a deadline, a named person. All four.
- What came out
- On 22 October the company cut the year to about 6%.
- Measured
- The middle of the promise was 9%. About 6% is a third below it: more than 30% off.
- Stamp
- Broken, Big miss, provisional until the 2026 annual report.
- Score
- 0 → −18.6 (the margin landed 25% below the bottom of the range: outcome −0.62, times 30 points).
- The company's reason
- Low activity in the first half and a restructuring in the third quarter. Before those costs, the third-quarter margin was 10.3%. Printed in full on the card's report page.
Every verdict links to its source.
Each card links to the page where the promise was made and the page where the result was reported: the company's own document or stock exchange announcement where one exists, otherwise a named, reputable outlet. I open every link before publishing, and again later: every card says the day its sources were last checked, and the oldest are opened again first. A search result is never a source. The company's reason is printed in its own terms, and nothing is added that the sources do not say. Before anything goes up, I read every verdict the way a media lawyer would.
The cards can be copied in an afternoon. The record cannot.
Anyone can copy the look of a card. What cannot be copied is a dated verdict that was public before the answer was known. Since 20 October 2026 I have published 92 dated verdicts on named companies: 67 verdict lines in the Morning Brief, 18 settled promises here and 7 columns. Each stays where it was published, with its date. Past editions of the Morning Brief stay in the archive as they stood that morning, and every change to a card is in the corrections log below.
When a call I made before a court filing is later confirmed by one, it goes on Verdicts that came true, with both dates. So far: 1.
The company gets its say.
Before a harsh verdict on a Danish company goes up, I send it to the company first, with time to reply. Until then the card waits. Any reply I receive, from any company, is added to its card with the date it arrived. Companies can write through the press page.
No stakes. Ever.
I have no stake in any company on these pages. No company pays to be checked, to be left out or to be scored again. Where I give my own call on a card, it is marked as mine, and it is really mine. This is an opinion on businesses, not investment advice.
When I am wrong, it says so here.
A wrong number, date or stamp is fixed on the card the day I learn of it, and logged below with the date and what changed. Nothing is corrected silently. Spotted a mistake? Tell me through the press page.
- 1 November 2026 · Intrum: Re-checked. Added Intrum's own Q3 2026 report as the first result source, so the date on the card opens the company's release instead of a news site. Promise, stamp and score unchanged.
- 1 November 2026 · DSV: Re-checked. Added the stock exchange copy of announcement 1175 as a second result source. Promise, stamp and score unchanged.
- 1 November 2026 · Starbucks: Wording: "then gave up" replaced by the sourced fact, "then suspended the forecast". Stamp and score unchanged.
- 1 November 2026 · General Motors: Wording: "GM gave up the goal" replaced by the sourced fact, "GM dropped the goal in October 2023". Stamp and score unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Embla Medical: Re-rated from Clear miss to Big miss. The promise was cut three times, and the method counts a promise cut more than once as a Big miss. Score 90 → 85.
- 31 October 2026 · Columbus: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Søren Krogh Knudsen 50 → −18.6. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Delta Air Lines: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Ed Bastian 70 → −13.1. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Embla Medical: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Sveinn Sölvason 85 → +4.5. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · DSV: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Jens H. Lund 90 → −5.1. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Intrum: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Andrés Rubio 50 → −37.3. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Coloplast: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Kristian Villumsen 95 → −2.5. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Pandora: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Alexander Lacik 105 → +14.3. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Ambu: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Britt Meelby Jensen 105 → +10.9. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Ford Motor: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Jim Farley 70 → −10.4. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · General Motors: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Mary Barra 60 → −18.7. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · The Walt Disney Company: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Robert A. Iger 105 → +17.5. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Pfizer: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Albert Bourla 105 → +6.0. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Starbucks: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Howard Schultz 60 → −23.5. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Novonesis: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Ester Baiget 105 → +14.7. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Vestas: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Henrik Andersen 105 → +7.4. The stamp is unchanged.
- 31 October 2026 · Ferrari: Rescored under the new method (everyone starts at 0, one decimal): Benedetto Vigna 105 → +24.7. The stamp is unchanged.
The rules, dated.
A method you can change quietly is not a method. Every change to the rules on this page is listed here, newest first. Changes never rescore old cards without a line in the corrections log.
- 2 November 2026 · Wrote down how a promise is found and the four dates every card carries, and added the record: how many dated verdicts are published, since when, and the early calls a later court filing confirmed.
- 1 November 2026 · Every card now shows the day its sources were last checked; the five oldest were opened again today. Next to a verdict there is now only the sourced verdict, the company's reason and the lines that tell you who answers for it; wording that said more than the record was replaced by the fact, each change in the corrections log.
- 31 October 2026 · New score: everyone starts at 0, on −100 to +100 with one decimal. Each check counts how far the result landed from the promise, how bold the promise was and whether it came on time, and older checks fade (half the weight every three years). All 16 cards rescored; each is in the corrections log.
- 31 October 2026 · Wrote down how a miss is measured (against the middle of a range), what a provisional stamp is, a worked example, and this log.
- 30 October 2026 · How far off a miss was is now said in three plain words: Near miss, Clear miss, Big miss. Corrections log opened. Coverage widened to C25 and S&P 100 leaders, kept promises included.
- 26 October 2026 · First version. Four tests, five stamps, everyone starts at 100.